Most bettors track profit, which is the number that takes longest to say anything. Four things are worth measuring instead.
Free. No account and no subscription. Needs macOS 14 or later on a Mac with Apple silicon (M1 or later). 34.9 MB, notarised by Apple.
Closing line value. Converges far faster than profit and is what sportsbooks themselves use to identify sharp accounts.
Return with its interval. A 220-bet record showing 5.91% sounds decisive and is not: the interval runs -7.0% to 18.9%, spanning zero.
Money return against flat-bet return. One is what happened, the other is what would have happened staking level. The gap is the only direct read on whether your sizing is earning its keep.
How many slices you checked. Tag your bets and each tag is a hypothesis. With 10 tags there is a 40% chance one clears the ordinary bar by luck, so the bar has to rise with the count. Slicing until something looks good is a search, not a test. What a record can prove →
What to write down for every bet
The price you took and the stake, the book, the sport and the market, and the time you placed it. After the game: the result, and the closing price on both sides of the market, so the close can be devigged. Anything you might later want to slice by goes in as a tag at the time, not reconstructed afterwards.
The closing price on the other side is the field most logs leave out, and it is the one that turns a raw closing line into a fair one.
Three bets, three answers
A short log, each closing market devigged by the engine:
| Taken | Stake | Result | Closed | Profit | CLV |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| +110 | 100 | won | -105 / -115 | +110.00 | +2.56% |
| -120 | 50 | lost | -130 / +110 | -50.00 | -0.01% |
| +150 | 25 | lost | +140 / -160 | -25.00 | -0.22% |
Money return: +35.00 on 175 staked, +20.00%. Flat return, one unit on each: -0.90 units over 3, -30.00%. The record is up because the largest stake happened to win, not because the picks were good on average.
Closing line value says something different again. It averages +0.78% across the three, and each figure is a statement about the price you took against where the market finished, which a result cannot change. Over a few hundred bets that column settles long before the profit column does.
When to look at which number
Every week: closing line value, since it is the one with enough signal to read at small samples.
Every few hundred bets: flat return with its interval, to see whether the picks themselves are earning.
Alongside it: money return, and the gap between the two, to see whether your sizing helps or hurts.