A SmartStake alternative that puts an interval around the return

By Matt Kerr · Updated

Bookbreaker is free and runs on your Mac, with no account. SmartStake offers EV, arbitrage, middles, promos and a tracker in one plan. Its price: Premium (with +EV and arbitrage) $99/mo billed monthly or $999/yr; Fantasy $49/mo (read 2026-11-04, source).

Free. No account and no subscription. Needs macOS 14 or later on a Mac with Apple silicon (M1 or later). 34.9 MB, notarised by Apple.

What SmartStake does not tell you

No interval on the EV it reports and no correction for slicing a record.

At SmartStake's prices the cheapest monthly plan costs $588 a year you clear before any profit is yours. That is 25 bets a month at a $100 stake and a two percent edge, every month, just to break even on average (read 2026-11-04, source).

Side by side

  SmartStake, as published Bookbreaker, as computed
Price Premium (with +EV and arbitrage) $99/mo billed monthly or $999/yr; Fantasy $49/mo (read 2026-11-04, source) Free. 34.9 MB, no account
What it advertises EV, arbitrage, middles, promos and a tracker in one plan (read 2026-11-04, source) 26 venues catalogued across 51 states
The gap we recorded No interval on the EV it reports and no correction for slicing a record (read 2026-11-04, source) An interval on the return, corrected for how many slices were tried

Each SmartStake cell is what SmartStake published on the date beside it, linked to where it was read.

What a record actually supports

Interval on a 220-bet record

-7.0% to +18.9%around a headline 5.91%

Realised edge

3.37%of a 4% edge, once the chance of the fill is priced in

Devig spread

0.39%how far four defensible methods disagree about one price

Slicing a record by sport, market and book produces dozens of returns, and the best of them is high partly because it was the best of dozens. Without an interval and a correction for how many slices were tried, a tracker reports luck as skill.

Why every tool in this list has the same blind spot →

Prices change. This one carries the date it was read.