You slice your record by sport, by book, by market, by day of week. One slice is clearly your best. It is probably nothing.
Free. No account and no subscription. Needs macOS 14 or later on a Mac with Apple silicon (M1 or later). 34.9 MB, notarised by Apple.
A 95% bar means a coin-flip record clears it one time in twenty per test. Run the test on several slices and the chance that at least one looks good by luck stops being small:
| Slices tested | Chance one looks real by luck | Bar it should clear |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 5.0% | z = 1.96 |
| 5 | 22.6% | z = 2.58 |
| 10 | 40.1% | z = 2.81 |
| 20 | 64.2% | z = 3.02 |
By 14 slices it is a coin flip that something in your record looks significant when nothing is. A bettor who invents tags until one of them looks profitable is not running a test. They are running a search, and a search needs a higher bar than z = 1.96: up to z = 3.02 at 20 slices.
What to do instead
Decide which slices matter before looking, and count every slice you tested, including the ones you abandoned. A slice under 30 settled bets should not be described at all. Not "slightly negative", not "promising", nothing.
This is the correction essentially nobody in this category applies, and tag breakdowns are exactly where it is needed. A tool that shows you twenty segments and highlights the green ones is selling you the search results and calling them a finding.
How to test a segment that looks good
Decide on the segment first, then judge it only on bets placed after that decision. Compare it with the same kind of bet made by everyone else in the same weeks, so a good season for the whole market does not pass for skill. And check it against the closing line rather than profit: a segment that beats the close is worth more attention than one that merely won.