Home/Guides

What is a sharp sportsbook

Why do some books' prices count as evidence and others don't?

A sharp book prices to be right. A soft book prices to be attractive. That difference decides whether a price is evidence about the world or a product being sold to you.

Free. No account and no subscription. Needs macOS 14 or later on a Mac with Apple silicon (M1 or later). 34.9 MB, notarised by Apple.

Sharp books run thin margins, take large bets, and do not limit winners. They can afford to because they treat informed money as information: a bet against their line tells them something, and they move. Soft books make money assuming the average customer loses, so a consistent winner breaks the model and gets cut.

Why it changes the arithmetic

A fair value is only as good as what anchors it. On the -145 / +125 moneyline the four devig methods span 57.11% to 57.50%, and that is the spread on a sharp price. Anchor the same calculation on a soft book and you are polling the people you intend to beat.

So a soft book adds very little weight to a fair value here. It is also never priced against a consensus it helped set. Even a small contribution pulls the number toward that book's own price, which shrinks the very edge being detected. It bites hardest where that book is the lone outlier and the edge is largest.

Using a sharp price where you cannot bet it

Most US bettors cannot place a bet at the sharpest books, but they can read their prices. Take the margin out of a sharp book's market and you have the best available estimate of the true chance. Any book that offers more than that on the same side is paying above fair, and that comparison, made one price at a time, is all positive expected value means.

Which books are which, by state →